Demand Is Holding Up Better Than the Stock Reaction Suggests
The bad news is Tesla’s March quarter deliveries came in below expectations. The company’s published consensus implied roughly 8% y/y growth, and some late whisper estimates were closer to 10%. That means the reported growth of 6.3% y/y is a miss, which explains the stock’s decline of 4% on the news when the Nasdaq was down.
The more important read is that this was one of the first clean quarters to judge underlying demand without the benefit of the U.S. tax credit. That credit had effectively lowered the price of Model 3 and Model Y by about 10% for roughly 30% of global Tesla buyers (I estimate 40% of sales are in the U.S., and 30% of total sales had qualified for the credit). Keep in mind that for a long time, a core part of the Tesla bear case was that the company could not sustain delivery growth without government support.
Part of the reason deliveries are increasing is that Tesla introduced lower-priced versions of the Model 3 and Model Y right after the credit expired, helping offset some of the lost affordability. My sense is those stripped-down versions have not been especially successful. Even so, the key point remains: Tesla returned to growth in a quarter where investors were looking for evidence that demand would falter without the subsidy.
